In 1964, Robert & Peggy Judge opened Judges', Beyond the Reef in Brookfield, Wisconsin. The Judges added an A-frame entrance to the original log cabin and some full-sized plastic palm trees out front that could handle a midwestern winter.
In tribute to them, it was called "Judges' Beyond the Reef".
Timeline uncertain, but the business was also owned and operated at some point by Frank E. Schuster, who passed away in 1999.