The first edition Trader Mort's mug was manufactured by Munktiki in 2006 and was a limited edition of 120. The mug features the face of the maori style tiki which still stands in front of Trader Mort's Liquor in Shelter Island, carved by Eli Hedley. The back features the Trader Mort's sign near the bottom of the mug. This second edition design was re-issued in a different shade of brown glaze by Munktiki Imports for 2018. The face takes up more of the front of the mug and the eyes and face are a bit more elongated and oval.